I asked my 6-year-old brother how his day was yesterday. “Not so good,” he answered. Surprised at hearing this response (he usually has a great disposition and tells me lots of good things about his day), I asked him why.
“Well, we had a fire drill today.” He starts explaining with a trembling voice. “And we had 2 groups, group A and group B. I was in group A. The teacher told group B they did great but she told my group that we should be ashamed of ourselves.” He started crying and gave the phone back to my mom.
I quickly tried to assure him and my mom that it probably wasn’t his fault, that it was the group the teacher was talking about and not him in specific. My efforts had little effect on the situation and it was clear that in his world this was a sort of catastrophe.
And then it hit me.
This is where it starts. As early as kindergarten, and even much earlier, we are taught to “be ashamed” of ourselves for our mistakes. We are taught to repress and feel guilty for not fitting in perfectly with a system of rules and protocols. So much of the time, we are clumped into groups (because it’s easier and quicker) instead of being encouraged as individuals for our particular talents and guided in a way that inspires rather than berates. Parents, teachers, organizations, we’re all guilty of doing this.
Take a quick look at today’s society (the historically high levels of depression, paralyzing anxiety, and fear of failure that probably you and most of the people you know have struggled with on some level) and it becomes obvious: The cumulative effect of such actions is devastating.
And it all starts with just one statement, repeated over and over in many different ways throughout your life: “You should be ashamed of yourselves.”
No, you shouldn’t.
True.
That’s a classic. Read it for my Russian Lit class last year. Best enjoyed with a side of City and Colour imo.